RE: Docket No. FDA-2013-N-0521, Menthol in Cigarettes, Tobacco Products; Request for Comments

September 8, 2013

Leslie Kux, Assistant Commissioner for Policy

c/o Division of Dockets Management (HFA-305)

U.S. Food and Drug Administration

5630 Fishers Lane, Rm. 1061

Rockville, MD 20852.

Dear Assistant Commissioner Kux:

On behalf of the American Conservative Union (ACU), the oldest and largest grassroots conservative organization in the nation, I am writing to express our strong opposition to the establishment of the Food and Drug Administration of a tobacco product standard for menthol in cigarettes.

As with most expansions of government authority, we believe that such a product standard, and especially an outright ban, would not only fail to achieve its ostensible goals – the promotion of smoking cessation and prevention of smoking by youth – but would in fact be counterproductive.  In addition, a menthol product standard or ban would have a significant negative effect on retailers and the economy, cost thousands of jobs, reduce state revenues, and greatly burden law enforcement, factors the FDA must consider in any rulemaking.

The unintended consequences of a menthol rule stem from the likelihood that banning or restricting menthol use would result in the dramatic expansion of the black market in cigarettes.  Menthol cigarettes currently comprise one-third of the market, providing a major opportunity for contraband activity and counterfeiters.  Numerous authorities, including the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, the Bureau of Alcohol, Firearms and Tobacco, the Government Accountability Office and the Virginia Crime Commission have confirmed the extensive current activities of counterfeiters.  Adding a monopoly on menthol cigarettes to their product offerings would dramatically expand their business.

 This black market represents a major public health challenge.  Counterfeit cigarettes have been found to contain far greater concentrations of harmful compounds, creating health risks that would more than offset any benefits of removing menthol.  Moreover, black-market operators, by avoiding taxation, sell their products below market price and do not respect laws restricting the sale of cigarettes to minors, therefore undercutting efforts to promote smoking cessation and prevent young people from starting the habit.  (Under the “We Card” initiative, retailers have reportedly reduced the success of underage smokers to purchase cigarettes from 76 percent to under six percent.)

For the same reason, an expansion of the black market would also cost the Federal government and states desperately needed revenues on top of an estimated loss of $5 billion annually due to contraband activity.  http://www.forbes.com/sites/kellyphillipserb/2013/08/20/up-in-flames-cigarette-taxes-create-opportunity-for-revenue-and-crime/

Retailers could be hit extremely hard.  According to various industry sources, cigarettes account for between 30 and 40 percent of sales by convenience stores, which provide more than five million desperately needed jobs. Eliminating all sales of menthol cigarettes could cost $7.6 billion and lead to price increases for non-tobacco products.

And of course, by definition any new counterfeit activity would create new headaches for law enforcement and even national security concerns.  The BATF has noted that “(t)raditional organized crime,” terrorist groups and street gangs are all involved in contraband cigarette trafficking, and that it has become the subject of gang wars.  Counterfeit cigarettes have been used to fund criminal elements, and it has been estimated that 50 percent of contraband cigarettes originate in China.

Like many regulatory proceedings, the issue of whether to ban menthol cigarettes concerns questions of freedom and responsibility on the one hand and, on the other hand, the use of government force to compel preferred behavior. On that spectrum, the conclusion is obvious:  The government does not have the right to compel preferred behavior.

The integrity of science-based regulatory decisions demands that the FDA process not be façade for a foregone conclusion regarding menthol in cigarettes.   America does not need another unnecessary regulatory initiative that diminishes consumer freedom and personal choice.

Given the potential public health, economic, law enforcement and even security risks for unregulated cigarette marketing that could be produced by a menthol product standard or restriction on sales, it is clear that such an action would not be in the best interests of the public and would undermine important government objectives.  Accordingly, the American Conservative Union urges the FDA not to move forward with regulatory action in this regard.

Sincerely,

Larry Hart

Director of Government Relations

American Conservative Union

Join ACU

The ACU Blog

Remembering Stan Evans

Originally published by National Review  by John Fund    From a journalist whose career he kick-started I heard about the death at age

CPAC then and now

Originally posted by The Washington Times

By Craig Shirley

For those of us around in the early days, there was something bittersweet

Remembering M. Stanton Evans

Originally posted by Powerline

by STEVEN HAYWARD

Sad news this morning of the passing of M. Stanton Evans

The Washington Times CPAC 2015 Straw Poll Results

The Road to CPAC

USA Today: CPAC Attendees Discuss What they Are Looking for in a Presidential Candidate

Screen Shot 2015-03-04 at 10.57.57 AM

Conservatives attending the 2015 Conservative Political Action Conference tell USA TODAY what they are looking for in a presidential candidate. H. Darr Beiser, USA TODAY

The 15 Best Quotes From CPAC 2015

Screen Shot 2015-03-03 at 3.10.00 PM

Originally published on Townhall.com

by John Hawkins

15) “I close with two words, ‘Kill ISIS!’ God bless you all!” — Mark Levin

CBS Philly’s Giordano: CPAC This Year Was Better Than Ever

Screen Shot 2015-03-02 at 10.35.05 PM

Originally published by CBS Philadelphia

By Dom Giordano

PHILADELPHIA (CBS) — CPAC this year was better than ever. This was my third visit

Founded in 1964, the American Conservative Union (ACU) is the oldest and largest grassroots conservative organization in the nation. For more than forty years, ACU has served as an umbrella organization harnessing the collective strength of conservative organizations fighting for Americans who are concerned with liberty, personal responsibility, traditional values, and strong national defense. As America's premier conservative voice, ACU is the leading entity in providing conservative positions on issues to Congress, the Executive Branch, State Legislatures, the media, political candidates, and the public. Read More

1331 H St NW Suite 500
Washington, DC 20005
Ph: (202) 347-9388 | Fx: (202) 347-9389

Contact Us
Privacy Policy
Opportunities/Careers

ACU. All Rights Reserved.